Every chopped cheese at Choppedcheese Deli is built with the same precision and passion that made New York's deli scene legendary — right here in the heart of Baldwinsville.
From the iconic chopped cheese to loaded hoagies and classic deli plates — every item is prepared with premium ingredients and real technique.
Choppedcheese Deli was born from a simple belief: that the best sandwiches aren't fast — they're made with intention. Our founder brought the authentic chopped cheese tradition from New York's deli scene and planted it right here in the Finger Lakes.
Every sandwich is chopped, cooked, and assembled the way it should be — on the griddle, with real cheese melted in, on a fresh roll. No shortcuts. No compromises. Just honest, flavorful food made for people who know the difference.
Ingredients sourced and prepared every single day — never frozen, never rushed.
Every sandwich is handcrafted with attention to the details that make it memorable.
A local spot for locals — where regulars are known by name and every visit feels like home.
We rotate our specials daily so there's always something new to try. Here's what's on the grill this week.
Any chopped cheese sandwich served with crispy fries and a drink. The perfect midweek treat.
Lunch SpecialAny hoagie with a side of our signature crispy fries. Pair it with a cold drink and make it a night.
Evening SpecialChoose any plate — jerk chicken, fried chicken, or hot ham & cheese — served with two sides and a drink.
Weekend Brunch"Best chopped cheese I've had outside of NYC. The Baldwinsville Special is absolutely unreal — loaded, perfectly seasoned, and the bread is always fresh. This place is a hidden gem."
"I drive past a dozen delis to come here. The jerk chicken plate is outstanding — perfectly spiced, generous portions, and the sides are always hot and fresh. This is my go-to lunch spot."
"Finally, a deli in the area that takes sandwiches seriously. The meatball sub is incredible — you can tell they make it from scratch. Great vibes, friendly staff, and real food."
We're right in the heart of downtown Baldwinsville. Walk in, order, and taste the difference fresh-made food makes.
34 E Genesee St
Baldwinsville, NY 13027-2502
Mon – Fri: 8:00 AM – 8:00 PM
Sat – Sun: 9:00 AM – 7:00 PM
